🏆 BassMatthi’s Platform Power Rankings — Top 10s & Hall of Shame
What this is
Top 10 games per platform for BassMatthi, plus a Top 5 to AVOID per platform. His Backloggd backlog is small (45 games) relative to his 426 played, so this leans harder on curated (✨) picks than my own doc — searching his played list, ratings, favorites and wishlist for taste signal rather than strip-mining a backlog that’s mostly already covered by good instincts. Companion-style doc to Backlog Picks — Platform Top 10s.
🧬 The Taste Profile (how these were picked)
Distilled from his 426 played games, ratings, and favorites (Silksong, Rhythm Doctor, Tunic, CrossCode, UFO 50):
- ❤️ Loved (5★ or favorited): Hollow Knight & Silksong, Celeste, Undertale, the Rayman trilogy, Cuphead, Outer Wilds (+ Echoes of the Eye), Baba Is You, Animal Well, Blue Prince, Void Stranger, Inscryption, CrossCode, UFO 50, Stardew Valley, the Rhythm Heaven series, Rhythm Doctor, Geometry Dash, A Dance of Fire and Ice, Doki Doki Literature Club, It Takes Two, Mario Kart Wii → precision platformers/metroidvanias, rhythm games, logic-puzzle games, and roguelike deckbuilders are the four pillars.
- ⚔️ Crucially, unlike my own list: he does not avoid difficulty — Sekiro (4.5★), Celeste (5★), Hollow Knight (5★) prove he’s got a genuinely high pain tolerance for “fair but hard.” Souls-likes are safe recommendations here in a way they aren’t for me.
- 💔 Cooler on: Man of Medan (1.5★ — bad narrative-choice horror), Cook Serve Forever (2.5★ — sequel fatigue after loving CSD 1–3), Haven (2.5★), Sonic Unleashed (2.5★), Fall Guys/Cookie Clicker/Cauldron (3★ — shrug at pure-idle or low-depth party games) → mild allergy to shallow idle loops and to narrative games where “choices” feel arbitrary rather than systemic.
- 📝 Key quote-equivalent: favorites are Silksong, Rhythm Doctor, Tunic, CrossCode, UFO 50 — an anthology game, a rhythm game, a “figure it out yourself” action-adventure, an action-RPG, and a metroidvania. Variety-seeking, systems-curious, unafraid of a learning curve.
- 🎯 Also notable: Drakengard, EarthBound, and NieR: Automata are sitting on his wishlist — genuine taste overlap with my own profile, which shaped a few curated picks below.
🗺️ Legend
📦 in his backlog/wishlist · ✨ curated addition (not on his lists) · ⚠️ caution flag · ⏳ play something else first
⏱ ~Xhmain-story time from HowLongToBeat ·🏷 Genre· [↗] opens Backloggd ·[[wikilinks]]for future per-game notes
🧭 Jump to a platform
Main libraries: 🖥️ PC (Steam) · 🔴 Switch Sony: 💿 PlayStation 4 (+PS5 dept) · 💿 PlayStation 3 · 💿 PlayStation 1 (nostalgia era) Nintendo: 🔵 Wii · 🔵 Wii U Xbox: 🟢 Xbox 360 Handhelds: 🎒 Handhelds (GBA · DS · 3DS · PSP · Vita)
🖥️ PC (Steam)
🥇 Tunic 📦 (favorited)
⏱ ~11h🏷 Action Adventure · Zelda-likeBackloggd ↗ Already a stated favorite and, notably, still unlogged as played on his profile — a real gap. A wordless instruction-manual mystery wrapped around a tiny fox in a tiny Souls-lite combat system. Everything his profile says he wants: cryptic systems, fair difficulty, huge “oh!” moment.
⏱ ~8h🏷 Action RPG · Pixel ArtBackloggd ↗ Wordless, gorgeous, brutal-but-fair combat from a Zelda/Souls lineage — the closest thing to “Hollow Knight but top-down action-RPG.” Short enough not to overstay.⏱ ~8h🏷 Action RPG
🥉 Noita ✨
⏱ ~20h+🏷 Roguelike · Physics SimBackloggd ↗ The logic-puzzle brain (Baba Is You, Human Resource Machine) meets the roguelike-deckbuilder brain (Hades, Balatro, Isaac) in one wand-building physics sandbox. Deep systems, huge “wait, I can do THAT?” ceiling.
⏱ ~27h🏷 Narrative RPGBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged — bumping it up. A skill-check RPG where the “combat” is arguing with your own brain. The systemic-choice game that makes Man of Medan’s arbitrary choices look thin by comparison.
#5 NieR: Automata 📦 (GOTY edition wishlisted)
⏱ ~30h all routes🏷 Action RPGBackloggd ↗ Already on his wishlist. Structurally an anthology like UFO 50 or Rhythm Heaven — routes stack into a different game each time — with combat sharp enough to satisfy the Sekiro itch.
#6 Cocoon ✨
⏱ ~6h🏷 Puzzle AdventureBackloggd ↗ From an ex-Playdead veteran: nest worlds inside orbs you carry between each other. Baba Is You-brained, gorgeous, no combat, no filler — 6 tight hours.
⏱ ~15h🏷 Metroidvania · Souls-liteBackloggd ↗ Melancholic, rain-soaked metroidvania with Souls-lite bosses. If Hollow Knight and Silksong are 5★, this is the next rung down worth climbing.
#8 Rain World 📦 ⚠️
⏱ ~20h🏷 Survival Platformer · Ecosystem SimBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged. Punishing but fascinating — a living ecosystem sim wearing a platformer costume. Flag: real difficulty curve, closer to “learn the rules or die” than Celeste’s assist-mode mercy.
#9 Subnautica 📦
⏱ ~30h🏷 Survival ExplorationBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged. Outer Wilds’ curiosity-first exploration loop underwater, with crafting that never turns into busywork.
⏱ ~12h🏷 Metroidvania · Party-SwapBackloggd ↗ An underrated metroidvania with three swappable characters and real Zelda-dungeon-brain puzzle design. Punches well above its budget.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- The Dark Pictures Anthology: Man of Medan
⏱ ~5h🏷 Choice-Driven Horror📦 — Already played and rated 1.5★. The rest of the anthology (Little Hope, House of Ashes) repeats the same “your choices barely matter” problem — skip the series, not just this entry.- Cook Serve Forever
⏱ ~10h🏷 Cooking Sim📦 — Already played, 2.5★ after loving CSD 1–3. The sequel-fatigue pattern: same loop, diminishing returns. Replay CSD3 instead if the itch returns.- Haven
⏱ ~12h🏷 Action RPG · Relationship📦 — Already played, 2.5★. The couple-focused narrative wrapped around a repetitive, floaty combat/traversal loop — style over substance.- Sonic Unleashed
⏱ ~14h🏷 Platformer📦 — Already played, 2.5★. Werehog sections turn a speed game into a brawler nobody asked for. The Days Gone problem in Sonic form.- Cauldron
⏱ ~3h🏷 Roguelike · Board Game📦 — Already played, 3★. A thin idle-adjacent loop dressed as a roguelike; the shallow-systems pattern (Cookie Clicker, Fall Guys) he consistently shrugs at.
🔴 Switch
🥇 Chicory: A Colorful Tale 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~14h🏷 Adventure · Coloring BookBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. A Zelda-shaped adventure where the “weapon” is a paintbrush that colors the whole (literally black-and-white) world. From ex-Wandersong devs; deals directly with self-doubt as a mechanic — genuinely moving.
🥈 Blasphemous II 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Metroidvania · Souls-liteBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. He rated the original 4★ — the sequel keeps the grim Iberian-Catholic iconography and smooths out the exploration and combat. Direct sequel to a proven hit.
🥉 Metroid Dread 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~9h🏷 MetroidvaniaBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. The genre’s current gold standard: tight, mean, gorgeous, exactly the “fair but hard” the Sekiro/Hollow Knight ratings ask for.
#4 Shovel Knight Dig 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~6h🏷 Roguelike · PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted; he’s played the original Shovel Knight. A Spelunky-shaped roguelike remix of a series he already knows — low-risk, high-familiarity pick.
#5 Neon White 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~6h🏷 Speedrun FPS · CardBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. A deckbuilding brain (cards as guns/movement) fused with Titanfall-speed level design and instant restarts — Celeste’s retry-friendliness in FPS form.
#6 Cairn 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~10h🏷 Climbing · PrecisionBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. A pure-movement mountain-climbing game with no combat — precision-platformer instincts pointed at something completely different from Celeste’s genre.
#7 Wilmot Works It Out 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~4h🏷 PuzzleBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. From the Baba Is You publisher; jigsaw-shaped self-arranging puzzle logic. Short, clever, in the exact logic-puzzle lane he keeps rating 5★.
#8 Donkey Kong Bananza 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~18h🏷 3D Platformer · DestructionBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. Odyssey-style movement joy plus fully destructible terrain — the Mario Galaxy love, evolved.
|Unbeatable]] 📦 (wishlisted)
⏱ ~8h🏷 Rhythm · NarrativeBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. A rhythm game with a real narrative arc about AI and music culture — feeds the Rhythm Heaven/Rhythm Doctor pillar directly.
#10 Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart 📦 (wishlisted, PS5; also on PS5)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Action PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Listed here as a reminder it’s wishlisted — cross-reference with the PS5 note below; play on whichever hardware is available first.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Balan Wonderworld
⏱ ~11h🏷 Platformer✨ — A one-button platformer that wastes its own costume gimmick 80 times over. The opposite of the “systems that reward curiosity” pillar.- Yoshi’s Crafted World
⏱ ~8h🏷 Platformer✨ — Gorgeous diorama aesthetic, but shallow, low-challenge platforming with no room for the precision-platformer itch that Celeste satisfies.- Fitness Boxing
⏱ ~varies🏷 Exergame✨ — Party/wellness shovelware in the Wii Fit lineage; no depth to reward repeat play.- Mario Party Superstars
⏱ ~10h🏷 Party✨ — Fine with a group, empty solo — and his Fall Guys 3★ suggests party games without systems depth land lukewarm here too.- Marvel’s Midnight Suns
⏱ ~45h🏷 Tactics · Card✨ — A genuinely interesting card-tactics system buried under 40 hours of base-building filler and licensed-fanservice bloat — the “too much for what it is” profile.
💿 PlayStation 4 (+PS5 dept)
🥇 Hades 📦 (played and loved — 4.5★)
⏱ ~22h🏷 Roguelike · ActionBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated 4.5★ on PC — flagged here as the platform’s benchmark. If somehow not yet played on a Sony console, this is still the #1 reason to own one for this profile.
🥈 Furi 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 Boss Rush · ActionBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as the platform’s identity: a pure boss-rush with a neon-synth soundtrack, exactly the “fair but brutal” lane Sekiro and Hollow Knight sit in.
🥉 Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart 📦 (wishlisted, PS5)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Action PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already wishlisted. Weapon-and-gadget joy with dimension-hopping traversal; a blockbuster with real craft behind the spectacle.
#4 Astro Bot 📦 (backlogged)
⏱ ~13h🏷 3D PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged. Generous, funny, mechanically inventive — the platform’s own Game of the Year, and pure friction-free platforming joy.
#5 Stray 📦 (backlogged & wishlisted)
⏱ ~7h🏷 Adventure · CatBackloggd ↗ On both his backlog and wishlist — a clear signal. A short, atmospheric cyberpunk city seen from a cat’s eye level; low-stress, high-charm.
#6 Sifu 📦 (backlogged)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Martial Arts · RogueliteBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged. Age-based permadeath turns every death into a system, not just a punishment — a roguelike brain grafted onto a kung-fu brawler.
#7 A Plague Tale: Innocence 📦 (backlogged)
⏱ ~12h🏷 Stealth AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged, with Requiem already wishlisted for after. A sibling-bond stealth adventure with a genuinely great rat-swarm gimmick.
#8 Death Stranding 📦 (backlogged, incl. Director's Cut)
⏱ ~41h🏷 Strand · Action AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already backlogged in both editions. A slow-burn delivery-and-connection game that rewards patience the way Subnautica or Outer Wilds do — pick whichever edition is on hand.
#9 Control 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Action Adventure · Sci-FiBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as benchmark. Remedy’s Metroidvania-shaped brutalist office building; if it wasn’t finished, it’s worth returning to.
#10 Nine Sols 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~16h🏷 Metroidvania · Souls-liteBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★), noted for completeness — Taoist-punk Sekiro-lite metroidvania, squarely in his favorite genre triangle.
🎮 PS5 dept.
Astro Bot, Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart, and Donkey Kong Bananza (Switch) form a clean “generous 3D platformer” throughline across his current wishlist — whichever console is on hand, one of these should be next.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- The Order: 1886
⏱ ~7h🏷 Cover Shooter✨ — Gorgeous, linear, mechanically empty. No systems to engage the puzzle/roguelike brain at all.- Days Gone
⏱ ~37h🏷 Open-World Action✨ — 40 hours of open-world errands for 10 hours of story — the Sonic Unleashed/Cauldron “bloated filler” pattern at AAA scale.- Marvel’s Avengers
⏱ ~15h🏷 Action · Live Service✨ — Loot-grind systems bolted onto a game with nothing to say; a live-service husk.- Balan Wonderworld
⏱ ~11h🏷 Platformer✨ — (Also flagged on Switch.) Wastes its own gimmick 80 times over.- Bright Memory: Infinite
⏱ ~2h🏷 FPS✨ — A tech demo pretending to be a full game; competent movement with nothing built on top of it.
💿 PlayStation 3
🥇 Dark Souls 📦 (played, currently in his backlog too — likely a replay itch)
⏱ ~44h🏷 Action RPG · Souls-likeBackloggd ↗ Already played — sitting on both played and backlog lists, suggesting an active replay/completion interest. Flagged as the platform-defining pick for a profile that rates Sekiro 4.5★ and Hollow Knight 5★.
🥈 Rayman Origins 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated a perfect 5★ — flagged as the platform’s benchmark for the whole Rayman-love throughline (Rayman 1 is also a 5★).
🥉 Rayman Legends 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~10h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated 5★ — the Origins sequel, kept as a paired benchmark entry.
#4 Dust: An Elysian Tail 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~10h🏷 MetroidvaniaBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark, and a reminder the metroidvania pillar runs deep even into 2011-era indie darlings.
#5 Guacamelee! 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~7h🏷 Metroidvania · BrawlerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). Its direct sequel Guacamelee! 2 (2018) is the natural next step wherever it’s available — luchador-metroidvania done twice as well.
#6 Salt and Sanctuary 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~20h🏷 Metroidvania · Souls-likeBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). 2D Dark Souls, essentially — the Souls-like and metroidvania pillars fused into one game, flagged as benchmark.
#7 Bastion 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~5h🏷 Action RPG · NarratedBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — Supergiant’s debut, flagged as benchmark ahead of Hades. Narrated combat, gorgeous isometric art, tight runtime.
#8 Limbo 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~3h🏷 Puzzle PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★). Three hours of monochrome trial-and-death puzzle platforming that never overstays.
#9 Psychonauts 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~10h🏷 Platformer · ComedyBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★), with Psychonauts 2 also played and loved on PC. Flagged here as the platform benchmark for the pairing.
#10 Hotline Miami 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~4h🏷 Top-Down Action · RetroBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). Instant-death, instant-retry top-down brutality with a killer synth soundtrack — short, replayable, no fat.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Ride to Hell: Retribution
⏱ ~6h🏷 Open-World Action✨ — One of the most infamous disasterpieces of the generation. Broken on every axis.- Aliens: Colonial Marines
⏱ ~8h🏷 FPS✨ — Bait-and-switch marketing, broken AI, a promise the game never delivers on.- Sonic Unleashed
⏱ ~14h🏷 Platformer📦 — (Also flagged, PC — he already played and rated it 2.5★. Same disappointment, different disc.)- Duke Nukem Forever
⏱ ~9h🏷 FPS✨ — Fourteen years of development, zero vision, dated humor even at launch.- Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing
⏱ ~½h🏷 Racing✨ — Technically PC-native but ported everywhere as a meme; the “so broken it’s famous” hall-of-shame entry.
🟢 Xbox 360
🥇 Castle Crashers 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~7h🏷 Brawler · Co-opBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as platform benchmark. Beat-‘em-up joy with RPG-lite leveling; co-op makes it even better.
🥈 Shank 2 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~5h🏷 BrawlerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). A short, stylish, ultra-violent side-scrolling brawler with real weight to its combat.
🥉 Portal 2 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 PuzzleBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark. The logic-puzzle pillar (Baba Is You, 7 Billion Humans) traced straight back to its foundational text.
#4 Half-Life 2 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~13h🏷 FPSBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as benchmark, and the direct ancestor of the Portal games he loves.
#5 Payday 2 📦 (played)
⏱ ~40h+🏷 Co-op Heist ShooterBackloggd ↗ Already played — flagged for completeness; a heist-planning systems game that rewards repeat play with better crews and better plans.
#6 The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim 📦 (played)
⏱ ~34h main🏷 Open-World RPGBackloggd ↗ Already played — flagged for completeness as the platform-era open-world benchmark, if a replay itch ever hits.
#7 Rogue Legacy 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~11h🏷 Roguelike · MetroidvaniaBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). Metroidvania exploration fused with roguelike meta-progression through generations of your own descendants — a genuine pillar-crossover pick.
#8 Child of Light 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~12h🏷 JRPG · Turn-BasedBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). Ubisoft’s watercolor JRPG with active-time-battle combat and real fairy-tale sincerity.
#9 Crypt of the NecroDancer 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~8h🏷 Rhythm · RoguelikeBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark for the rhythm×roguelike pillar-crossover, arguably his single most “on-brand” genre mashup.
#10 Awesomenauts 📦 (played)
⏱ ~varies🏷 MOBA PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played — a 2D MOBA/brawler hybrid, flagged for completeness as a lighter multiplayer option from the same era.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days
⏱ ~6h🏷 TPS✨ — Deliberately ugly “found footage” filter over genuinely bad shooting mechanics.- Aliens: Colonial Marines
⏱ ~8h🏷 FPS✨ — (Also flagged, PS3.) Same disaster, same disc drive.- Fuse
⏱ ~8h🏷 Cover Shooter · Co-op✨ — Insomniac’s most forgettable game: generic co-op shooter with none of their usual gadget creativity.- Amy
⏱ ~4h🏷 Survival Horror✨ — Infamous for its broken escort-AI and unresponsive controls. A “concept sounded fine on paper” cautionary tale.- Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric
⏱ ~9h🏷 Action Platformer✨ — The broken one, even by Sonic standards. (Xbox 360 got the equally-bad little sibling of the Wii U disaster.)
🔵 Wii
🥇 Super Mario Galaxy 📦 (played twice, 4.5★)
⏱ ~14h🏷 3D PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★, and logged a second time) — flagged as platform benchmark. Nintendo’s most inventive platformer, one idea per galaxy.
🥈 Rhythm Heaven Fever 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~7h🏷 RhythmBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated a perfect 5★ — flagged as platform benchmark for the entire rhythm-game pillar.
🥉 Ōkami 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~30h🏷 Action AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark. Clover’s painterly action-adventure; long but never padded.
#4 Muramasa: The Demon Blade 📦 (played)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Action RPG · 2DBackloggd ↗ Already played — Vanillaware’s gorgeous samurai side-scroller, flagged for completeness as a visually distinct action-RPG worth revisiting.
#5 The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~34h🏷 Action AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as benchmark, unlike my own OOT scars this profile clearly gets along fine with classic Zelda pacing.
#6 Punch-Out!! 📦 (played)
⏱ ~6h🏷 Boxing · Pattern MemorizationBackloggd ↗ Already played — flagged for completeness. Pure rhythm-adjacent pattern-reading disguised as a boxing game; fits the rhythm pillar surprisingly well.
#7 Fluidity 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~7h🏷 Puzzle PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — a genuine hidden-gem hit, flagged as benchmark: control a blob of water tilting through dioramas.
#8 LostWinds 📦 (played)
⏱ ~3h🏷 Platformer · Wind MagicBackloggd ↗ Already played, with the sequel Winter of the Melodias also played — flagged for completeness as a short, breezy WiiWare gem.
#9 The Last Story ✨
⏱ ~22h🏷 JRPGBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★). Sakaguchi’s compact, character-driven JRPG swan song for the console — noted for completeness alongside the Zelda/Galaxy benchmarks.
#10 New Super Mario Bros. Wii 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 Platformer · Co-opBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged for completeness as the reliable co-op couch pick.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Wii Music
⏱ ~3h🏷 Music · Motion✨ — Famously the “instrument simulator with no real feedback loop” — a rhythm-adjacent misfire despite his love of the genre elsewhere.- Red Steel
⏱ ~9h🏷 FPS · Motion✨ — Launch-window waggle-swordplay that fights the player constantly.- Sonic and the Secret Rings
⏱ ~9h🏷 Platformer · Rail✨ — On-rails Sonic controlled by tilting. Trial-and-error with motion controls layered on top.- Carnival Games
⏱ ~5h🏷 Minigames✨ — 12 million copies of shallow shovelware — the Fall Guys/Cookie Clicker problem at its most cynical.- Chicken Shoot
⏱ ~3h🏷 Light Gun✨ — Budget shovelware light-gun game with nothing resembling depth.
🔵 Wii U
🥇 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~50h🏷 Open World · Action AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as platform (and generational) benchmark. Also owned/played on Switch; whichever hardware, this anchors the platform.
🥈 Splatoon 📦 (played)
⏱ ~varies🏷 Shooter · MultiplayerBackloggd ↗ Already played — flagged for completeness as the console’s most inventive multiplayer identity piece.
🥉 Super Mario Galaxy 2 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~13h🏷 3D PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★, via Super Mario 3D All-Stars) — flagged as benchmark, paired with the original.
#4 Shovel Knight 📦 (played, backlogged too — completion itch)
⏱ ~5h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played, and also sitting in his backlog — likely signaling unfinished DLC campaigns (Plague of Shadows, Specter of Torment). Worth returning to for the full package.
#5 Stardew Valley 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~53h🏷 Farming SimBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated a perfect 5★ — flagged as benchmark, cross-platform comfort-food pick.
#6 Super Meat Boy 📦 (played, also backlogged)
⏱ ~5h🏷 Precision PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played, sitting in both played and backlog lists. The genre-defining precision platformer that sits right beside Celeste in his tastes.
#7 Terraria 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~var.🏷 Sandbox · CraftingBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged for completeness. A crafting/exploration loop with real systems depth, unlike the shallow idle games he rates lower.
#8 Human Resource Machine 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~6h🏷 Programming PuzzleBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as a pure hit for the logic-puzzle pillar (Baba Is You, 7 Billion Humans, Cosmic Express).
#9 Dark Souls 📦 (also on PS3; noted for the Wii U port trivia)
⏱ ~44h🏷 Action RPGBackloggd ↗ Cross-listed with PS3 — pick whichever platform is on hand for the replay itch his lists suggest.
#10 Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate 📦 (played, on 3DS too)
⏱ ~var.🏷 Action RPG · GrindBackloggd ↗ Already played on both Wii U and 3DS — flagged for completeness; systems-deep gear-grind that rewards the patience Elden Ring and Dark Souls already proved he has.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Star Fox Zero
⏱ ~7h🏷 Rail Shooter✨ — Forced dual-screen aiming that fights the player constantly.- Devil’s Third
⏱ ~8h🏷 Action Shooter✨ — Itagaki’s infamous mess: jank without vision, difficulty without fairness — the “hard for the wrong reasons” trap that the Sekiro/Celeste love doesn’t reward.- Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric
⏱ ~9h🏷 Action Platformer✨ — The broken one, even by Sonic standards.- Mario Party 10
⏱ ~5h🏷 Party✨ — The board game with the boards removed — the shallow-party-game problem again.- The Letter
⏱ ~½h🏷 Walking Sim✨ — eShop shovelware, 10 minutes of walking, nothing else.
💿 PlayStation 1 (nostalgia era)
🥇 Spyro: Year of the Dragon 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~11h🏷 Platformer · CollectathonBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated a perfect 5★ — flagged as the platform benchmark. The Spyro trilogy sits right beside Rayman as his defining childhood-platformer love.
🥈 Rayman 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~8h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (5★) — flagged as benchmark, the origin point of the whole Rayman throughline that runs all the way to Legends and the 30th Anniversary Edition (wishlisted).
🥉 Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage! 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~10h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark, the middle chapter of the trilogy.
#4 Wild 9 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~4h🏷 Action PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★). An underrated, grungy Rare-adjacent action platformer — a genuine hidden gem in his own history.
#5 Gran Turismo 2 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~var.🏷 Racing SimBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged for completeness as the era’s racing-sim high point, if the mood for a slower systems game hits.
#6 Tekken 3 📦 (played)
⏱ ~var.🏷 FightingBackloggd ↗ Already played, with Tekken and Tekken 2 also logged — flagged for completeness as the trilogy’s peak entry.
⏱ ~2h🏷 Puzzle ActionBackloggd ↗ A game about being a sentient domino. Twenty-something minutes of concept, zero fat — the kind of one-off weirdness his UFO 50 love suggests would land well.
#8 Driver 📦 (played, also on PS2/Xbox 360)
⏱ ~7h🏷 Racing · Open WorldBackloggd ↗ Already played across three platforms — flagged for completeness as a childhood staple, with Driver: San Francisco (PS3/360) as the modern payoff if a replay itch hits.
#9 Toy Story 2: Buzz Lightyear to the Rescue! 📦 (played)
⏱ ~6h🏷 Platformer · LicensedBackloggd ↗ Already played — flagged for completeness as a genuinely well-regarded licensed platformer from the same nostalgia shelf as Spyro/Rayman.
⏱ ~5h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Dreamy 2.5D platforming with a quietly devastating ending — same era, same “cute platformer, unexpectedly moving finale” beat as Rayman’s better moments.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Bubsy 3D
⏱ ~4h🏷 Platformer✨ — Widely cited as one of the worst 3D platformers ever made — a nostalgia-era warning label.- Extreme Pinball
⏱ ~2h🏷 Pinball✨ — Broken physics that undercut the entire genre it’s trying to be part of.- Superman
⏱ ~4h🏷 Licensed Action✨ — Licensed-game landfill; broken camera, broken combat.- Action Man: Operation Extreme
⏱ ~4h🏷 Licensed Platformer✨ — Forgettable toy-tie-in filler with none of Rayman/Spyro’s polish.- Chicken Run
⏱ ~5h🏷 Licensed Adventure✨ — Movie tie-in shovelware from the same shelf, minus the charm.
🎒 Handhelds (GBA · DS · 3DS · PSP · Vita)
🥇 Rhythm Heaven Megamix 📦 (played, 5★)
⏱ ~10h🏷 RhythmBackloggd ↗ Already played and rated a perfect 5★ — flagged as the handheld benchmark for the rhythm pillar, alongside the original DS Rhythm Heaven (also 5★).
🥈 The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~13h🏷 Action AdventureBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★) — flagged as benchmark, the gentlest, most charming Zelda and a genuine favorite here.
🥉 Wario Land 3 📦 (played, 4.5★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 Platformer · PuzzleBackloggd ↗ Already played (4.5★). A time-of-day puzzle-platformer with genuinely clever powers-as-keys design.
#4 Rayman Origins 📦 (played, 5★; also on PS3/360)
⏱ ~9h🏷 PlatformerBackloggd ↗ Already played (5★) — flagged again for the 3DS release specifically, since the Rayman love clearly justifies a portable copy too.
#5 Kid Icarus: Uprising 📦 (played, 4★)
⏱ ~9h🏷 Action · Rail ShooterBackloggd ↗ Already played (4★) — flagged as benchmark. Sakurai’s genre-hopping shooter/brawler hybrid with a genuinely funny script.
#6 Theatrhythm Final Bar Line 📦 (played)
⏱ ~var.🏷 Rhythm · JRPGBackloggd ↗ Already played, with Theatrhythm: Curtain Call also logged on 3DS — flagged as a direct rhythm-pillar hit wrapped in Final Fantasy nostalgia.
#7 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trilogy 📦 (backlogged, also played on multiple platforms)
⏱ ~60h all 3🏷 Visual Novel · CourtroomBackloggd ↗ Sitting in his backlog despite already being logged as played elsewhere — likely an unfinished playthrough. Logic-puzzle brain applied to courtroom contradictions.
⏱ ~11h🏷 MetroidvaniaBackloggd ↗ Mercury Steam’s 3DS remake with generous checkpoints; the metroidvania pillar’s portable-native pick alongside Dread.
#9 Half-Minute Hero ✨
⏱ ~7h🏷 RPG Parody · SpeedrunBackloggd ↗ JRPG deconstruction in 30-second bursts on PSP — constant novelty, zero friction, and a genuinely funny structural gimmick.
#10 Persona 4 Golden ✨
⏱ ~70h🏷 JRPG · Social SimBackloggd ↗ The definitive cozy-dark murder-mystery JRPG on Vita. Long, but structured in daily bites — a big systems-deep swing for when the Elden Ring/Dark Souls patience is available.
🚫 Top 5 to Avoid
- Sonic the Hedgehog Genesis
⏱ ~3h🏷 Platformer · Broken Port✨ — The infamous GBA port of Sonic 1: single-digit framerate, possibly the worst port ever sold.- Dragon Ball Evolution
⏱ ~5h🏷 Licensed Action✨ — Licensed-game landfill from the DS/PSP era.- Metroid Prime: Federation Force
⏱ ~11h🏷 Co-op FPS✨ — The wrong game with the right name; a bland co-op shell that disappointed on arrival.- The Rub Rabbits!
⏱ ~5h🏷 Minigames✨ — Shallow touch-minigame filler, the DS-era equivalent of the Fall Guys/Cauldron shrug.- Silent Hill: Origins
⏱ ~7h🏷 Survival Horror✨ — Outsourced fan-fiction Silent Hill with breakable-weapon busywork — style points that don’t survive the systems underneath.